Wiki woes

This semester I have had to abandon most of my wiki-based activities with my students, which has been disappointing and frustrating. Just to keep things fresh, I had switched to using a WetPaint wiki this year (last year I used Wikispaces). A few things went wrong with that.

1. Public Education Security

I hadn’t counted on the increased level of security that schools in our Board would implement this year. Many sites that I have used are now banned, and WetPaint’s “edit” function seems to fall under that. I can work to get it unblocked, but it’s a long, complicated process that I just haven’t gotten around to.

2. No Trial Run

I don’t really have an opportunity to fully test new systems before going live with my class. 30 students jumping onto a system, all with different user names, passwords, and privileges, is a lot different than me as a teacher working on it. It would have been nice to know about the WetPaint issue before the semester started, but it wasn’t something I was able to do.

3. No Flex Time

The lab at our school is booked solid. Once I recognized the issue with WetPaint, I could have perhaps taken the class in the next day, having moved their work to a Wikispaces wiki. Alas, there aren’t any spare minutes available for the lab, so mistakes really couldn’t be recovered.

I’m sure that there must be some lessons here for me: Maybe I should have a couple of wikis ready to go before the semester starts so that I can quickly switch to a working system if I need to? It seems like a lot of work.

—–

Image by Justin Marty

Can blogging really be incorporated into any classroom?

Orange Glow - Computer power cordI’ve noticed that a lot of us educators who are online blog about blogging. I do. I’m convinced that blogging, along with other Web 2.0 tools, is valuable in the classroom. It’s also enjoyable for me, a way to reflect on my practice and invite other perspectives.

But not everyone is that comfortable with technology. Lee LeFever of CommonCraft reflected on this recently:

I’m writing this because I’ve caught myself assuming too much lately and I’m hoping for new perspectives. While we spend so much time debating the merits of Twitter (for example), there is literally a world of people who are still perplexed by the basics of computers and the Web.

While he explains that this is based on anecdotal evidence, it rings true to me. There are people – educators – who have been using tools like blogs for years and are championing their application in the classroom. There are others like myself who are just starting to use these tools, enjoying the new discoveries they bring.

But there are a lot of people who just don’t like technology. They don’t like computers, often because computers represent work. The idea of spending an evening or two ‘playing’ with a blog or other tool strikes them as being about as appealing as extended study hall supervision does to me. Without playing with those applications, they remain slightly uneasy with them and understandably will do everything they can to avoid using them in a classroom with 20 teenagers watching.

The head of the English department at my school is supportive and visionary, and would like to see tools like blogs and wikis be embedded into course curriculum. I’m quite excited about this, but I’m wondering how this can work for others. Is there a way for educators who dislike using technology to still incorporate some aspect of these tools positively in the classroom?

It’s inevitable. It is simply a matter of time.

—–

Photo by Matthew Clark Photography and Design.

Lesson Debrief: Virtual Literature Circles (Part 2)

The wiki-based virtual literature circle experiment is continuing, and I feel that almost daily I’m learning from yet another mistake. I remain grateful for my long-suffering colleague who is collaborating with me.

What I like

  • I’m glad that I had a Code of Conduct (based on the Wiki Warranty by TeachersFirst) published and reviewed with students before they started using the wiki. Today I had my first vandalism experience, with a couple of students putting inappropriate content on other students’ pages. I took the opportunity to review the Code of Conduct with the whole class and then spoke individually with the offending students. It wasn’t a highlight, but the students seemed to accept and understand why they would be banned from the wiki for the rest of the unit.

What needs work

  • I wish that I had set every student up with a wikispace account ahead of time. That way I would know and control their passwords, which are prone to being lost and shared.
  • I wish I’d known about the gmail-plus option for setting up multiple addresses linked to the same gmail account when I’d started. Kim Cofino first introduced me to the idea of linked gmail accounts; Sean Deasy gives a quick summary of this cool gmail feature. Next time I’ll use linked gmail accounts to sign students up for our class blog and the class wiki just for my own sanity’s sake.
  • Trying to incorporate two novels into this experiment has been a bit much. College-level students can’t reliably read novels independently, so I plan to read aloud any novel we study. This gets tricky when I have two groups of students reading different novels in the same classroom. We’re surviving, but next time I do this with a college-level class I’ll just use one novel.

Two weeks left of the literature circle experiment …

—–

Related
Lesson Debrief: Virtual Literature Circles (Part 1)

Lesson Debrief: Virtual Literature Circles (Part 3)